It’s thicker than most liquid foundations and can apply a little streaky. I can see it clinging to the few flakes I have on my cheeks. Matchmaker doesn’t even flinch at oily skin, but it’s not as confident around the dry stuff.
Knock on wood, but so far Matchmaker hasn’t triggered any breakouts on my combination oily/dry/acne-prone skin (read: generally fussy), so that’s a big plus. I do notice that the reddish tones in 5.0 mellow out a bit after a few hours of wear and let through more of my natural skin tone, so maybe I just have to be a little more patient.
It may have something to do with the shade I’ve been using… 5.0 isn’t a perfect match for me it’s a little redder than my usual NC 42, but it was the closest shade I could find in the range to my skin. With Matchmaker, I feel like I have to pay closer attention to my contouring with bronzer, lest my skin look totally flat. I think my skin looks more natural when I wear Chanel Mat Lumiere, my current favorite foundation. Unfortunately, I think it’s almost too good at washing out the natural variations in my skin tone and texture that would keep it looking real. I almost don’t even care, though, because of how much I love the lightweight feel and how long it keeps the shine on my forehead at bay (for hours). Shade 5.0 definitely evens out my skin tone and covers everything I want it to cover, from the post-acne discoloring along my jawline (dang hormones have run amok!) to the light spots on my cheeks, but it doesn’t look completely natural to me.